USRussia–Ukraine War
US, Germany and UK differ over assessment of Ukrainian strikes inside Russia
Elbridge Colby questioned the military impact of Ukraine’s deep strikes, while the German and British defence ministers pushed back. The disagreement concerns priorities for support to Ukraine, but does not in itself mean a change in the conditions attached to aid.

On 17 November 2026, representatives of the US, Germany and the UK publicly expressed differing assessments of Ukrainian strikes deep inside Russian territory. At the Ukraine Defence Contact Group meeting at NATO headquarters in Brussels, US Under Secretary of Defense for Policy Elbridge Colby questioned the effectiveness of the strikes. The German and British defence ministers pushed back against the US criticism, Euronews reports.
This is a developing story and further information may be added.
Colby emphasised the front line and Russian supply lines
According to Colby, the US assessment is that deep strikes have neither brought the end of the war closer nor curbed the Russian advance. He called for support for Kyiv to focus on Ukrainian forces’ ability to hold the front line and, where possible, advance.
Colby also recommended medium-range strikes to disrupt supplies to Russian troops, reports Meduza, an independent Russian publication operating from Latvia.
The US official also linked his criticism to the risk of escalation. He said strikes on sites he describes as civilian infrastructure, including facilities belonging to Russian online retailer Wildberries, had probably strengthened Russian society’s resolve and the Kremlin’s willingness to escalate the conflict. This is Colby’s assessment of the campaign’s consequences.
Pistorius pushed back against the criticism, while Streeting defended the strikes
Boris Pistorius, Germany’s defence minister, described the US criticism as rather unreasonable. Instead, he insisted that allies should discuss and condemn Russian strikes on Ukraine’s energy, water and heating infrastructure, Euronews and Meduza report.
Wes Streeting, the British defence secretary, also believes that Ukrainian strikes have weakened Putin’s military capability and helped both to buy time and to save lives.
At the same meeting, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy urged allies to provide interceptor missiles for Patriot and IRIS-T air defence systems from their existing stocks, Romanian news publication HotNews.ro and Euronews report. The request is aimed at protection against air attacks, which serves a different purpose from deep-strike capabilities.
Disagreement over military impact, with no announced change in aid
In Flank’s assessment, the difference lies primarily in the criteria used to judge military results. Colby emphasises the immediate task of holding the front line and disrupting supplies, while Streeting highlights the broader impact on Russian military capability. These tasks are not necessarily mutually exclusive, but they can compete for limited resources.
The fact that the war has not ended quickly does not in itself prove an absence of military impact. Conversely, striking a distant target does not prove that it has had a significant effect on the front line. The remarks cited contain no comparable, measurable indicators of the duration of supply disruptions or their impact on Russian operations that would allow the dispute to be resolved.
The national positions expressed at NATO headquarters do not constitute a collective Alliance decision. They do not allow the conclusion that new restrictions have been imposed on aid or on permitted targets. The question remains whether the disagreement will lead to such decisions and to a change in delivery priorities. This article may be updated with further information.
Sources
2 independent reports1 secondary report
Independent reporting
Euronews · euronews.com
US criticises Ukraine's 'deep strike' campaign against RussiaVerified mediaMeduza · meduza.io
‘Quite a stupid thing’: German defense minister rejects U.S. criticism of Ukraine’s strikes deep inside RussiaVerified media
Secondary reporting
HotNews.ro · hotnews.ro
Numărul 2 din Pentagon critică atacurile Ucrainei în profunzimea teritoriului rus: „O sursă de escaladare”. Răspuns dur din partea GermanieiVerified media
Linked to this story
- Air DefencePatriot air and missile defence system
- Air DefenceIRIS-T SLM
Related topics

Bucharest, RomaniaGeopolitics
Romanian prime minister discusses closer strategic partnership with US
According to News.ro, Prime Minister Luca Niculescu discussed specific ways to deepen the strategic partnership between Romania and the US with Elbridge Colby, as well as security in the Black Sea region against the backdrop of Russia’s war in Ukraine. The report contains no specific decisions on additional forces or investment.

GermanyRussia–Ukraine War
Germany to provide $300 million for US weapons for Ukraine
Berlin will jointly fund new purchases from the US with Norway. PAC-2 and PAC-3 missiles for Patriot are the priority. The sum is Germany’s contribution, not the total value of the aid.

Dublin, IrelandRussia–Ukraine War
Von der Leyen: Europe’s team for the Ukraine peace talks will be the E5 together with the EU institutions
After the informal meeting of EU leaders in Dublin, the European Commission President said a team of France, Germany, Italy, Poland, the United Kingdom and the EU institutions has been agreed. Who exactly will represent Europe, and whether Russia will accept the wider format, has not been decided.

BrusselsRussia–Ukraine War
Turkey discusses Black Sea shipping safety with Russia and Ukraine
Hakan Fidan said Ankara was also consulting Bulgaria and Romania on the security of shipping and grain supplies. Turkey has specific proposals, but their contents and the outcome of the talks have not yet been disclosed.