Skip to main content
Incidents (7 days):17— Show on the map
Flank.bgDEFENCESECURITYGEOPOLITICS

Moscow, RussiaRussia–Ukraine War

Russia rejects US idea of security guarantees for Ukraine modelled on Article 5 of the NATO treaty

Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov said any form of "quasi-membership" of Ukraine in NATO is unacceptable to Moscow. The statement contradicts US negotiator Jared Kushner's claim that the Russians had accepted guarantees based on Article 5.

By Flank Editorial TeamEditor-in-chief: Martin NestorovPublished: ConfirmedRead in Bulgarian
Share
The red walls and tower of the Moscow Kremlin beside the river.
Archive photo: Petrovskaya Tower and the walls of the Moscow Kremlin, Moscow, July 2025.Photo: Retired electrician / Wikimedia Commons, CC0

Any form of "quasi-membership" of Ukraine in NATO is unacceptable to Moscow, Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov said on Friday. He also rejected so-called creative solutions for security guarantees for Ukraine modelled on the Alliance, The Moscow Times reported, citing Reuters.

According to Ryabkov, Ukraine must first accept Russia's "irrevocable" demand that it not join NATO. Only then can the question of security guarantees be discussed "in one way or another". He said Moscow is not closing the door to dialogue, but no option of NATO membership for Ukraine remains, BTA reported.

Article 5 and Kushner's words

US negotiator Jared Kushner said that together with Steve Witkoff he had got the Russians comfortable with the concept that any security guarantee for Ukraine would be based on Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty. Under that article an attack on one member state is considered an attack on all, and the allies are obliged to respond. Ryabkov's statement contradicts Kushner's account.

Ryabkov spoke a day after French President Emmanuel Macron said after the Coalition of the Willing meeting in Berlin that the question of Ukraine's NATO membership should be reopened.

European envoys to Moscow

Ryabkov confirmed that a possible visit to Moscow by representatives of the United Kingdom, Germany and France is being prepared. President Vladimir Putin said Russia had proposed that European envoys come to clarify their positions before the format of further talks is set.

German Defence Minister Boris Pistorius said rejecting the invitation would be "a completely inappropriate signal" and that it should be welcomed. He added, however, that concrete results matter more than statements and invitations, BTA reported, citing AFP.

Why This Matters for Bulgaria

What guarantees Ukraine receives will shape NATO's future force posture and security in the Black Sea region. As a member of the Alliance, Bulgaria is bound by Article 5 and directly affected by how the end of the war is negotiated.

Sources3

1 primary or official2 independent reports

We cite the source of every material fact. Unverified information is labelled as such.

Linked to this story

Share
Developing story

Berlin, GermanyRussia–Ukraine War

Coalition of the Willing to discuss Ukraine’s defence in Berlin

The meeting on 19 November will focus on funding Ukraine’s defence in 2027 and a common position for future peace talks, German Chancellor Friedrich Merz announced. Media reporting suggests US envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff are also expected in Berlin.

Updated: 2 min readSource: Official source

Subscribe to the Flank.bg newsletter

The essentials on defence and security in Bulgaria, the region and the Black Sea, in your inbox once a week.

  • The week's news in brief
  • The weekly analysis and new OSINT pieces
  • Incidents in the Black Sea
Follow Flank on Telegram too (in Bulgarian)

Just the newsletter, no ads. Unsubscribe at any time.

Newsletter

What matters in security — once a week

Just the newsletter, no ads. Unsubscribe at any time.